Showing posts with label Age based laws. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Age based laws. Show all posts

Monday, July 30, 2012

Teenage drinking and driving




Jessica  is 17 years old. She doesn't own a car, but she's been saving up money from her part time job to eventually purchase her own car in the near future. In the meantime, Jessica drives around her mother's car whenever she needs to.  Jessica is the only one among her friends who has a driver's licence, so her friends often depend on her to give them a ride.

One night there was a dance taking place at her school, and all the students were planning to attend.   Jessica was very excited for this dance because her exams were finally all over.  She was looking forward to partying and celebrating with her classmates. Many of Jessica’s friends were planning on getting wasted at the dance and she ensured them that she'd remain a designated driver for them. Although Jessica and her friends were below Ontario’s legal drinking age, they still planned to drink.

Jessica ended up drinking along with her friends during the party. She knew how dangerous it is to drink irresponsibly, but she continued to drink through the party along with her friends, even though she knew that she was supposed to drive everyone home safely.

Although Jessica didn't drink as much as her friends she still had a high amount of alcohol in her system , enough to possibly impair her driving ability.  Jessica has heard of the effects of drinking and driving countless times and she knows that drinking and driving can lead to accidents that claim lives.  She knows that driving home would put many innocent lives, including those of her friends, at risk.

Why does drinking and driving lead to accidents?

When a person drinks alcohol, it affects their ability to see and think about things the way that they normally do.  Ability to judge distances, to respond quickly to changes on the road, and to see clearly can all be affected.  All this means that accidents are more likely to happen when someone drinks and drives.

The amount of alcohol in a person’s body is measured by how much alcohol is in their blood.  This is called blood alcohol concentration, or BAC.  Your BAC is affected by factors like how much you drink, how fast you drink, your gender, your body weight, and how much food is in your stomach.  Because these factors change based on the individual person, it is very hard to know how much drinking will lead to impairment of your driving abilities.  It’s also very hard to assess your own BAC or impairment.  Overall, a higher BAC means that the alcohol you’ve drunk will have a greater impact on your driving performance.

What are the consequences of drinking and driving?

Drinking and driving leads to accidents, including death and injury.  It accounts for almost 25% of car accident deaths in Ontario.  However, it can also lead to charges being laid against the driver, fines and licence suspensions, and the impoundment of a vehicle.

In Ontario, if you are 21 and under, there is a zero blood alcohol concentration (BAC) rule while driving.  This means that regardless of which kind of licence you have (G, G1, G2), if you are caught with any alcohol in your blood, you will receive an immediate 24-hour roadside driver licence suspension.  You will likely then be charged with impaired driving.  If you are convicted of the charge, you can be fined between $60 and $500, and your licence can be suspended for 30 days.  If you are a young driver with a G1 or G2 licence, you can face even stricter consequences, including being returned to the start of the Graduated Licencing System.  For example, this means that if Jessica has her G2 and is caught drinking, she may lose her G2 licence (which allows her to drive her friends unaccompanied by an adult) and be returned to the start of the licensing process.

Higher BACs (between 0.05-0.08, and above 0.08) lead to even more severe consequences.

What are Jessica’s other options?

Jessica chose to drink even though she had agreed to be the designated driver.  Now  she has another decision to make: drive home or find alternative options.  If Jessica chooses to drive home, she risks the safety of herself, her friends, and others on the road.  She also risks being caught driving while impaired, either because of an accident or because she is stopped by a police officer, which could have a serious impact on her ability to drive.  If she drives home drunk, she will also have to consider what will happen if her mother finds out about what she has done.

Instead of driving home, Jessica can find out whether one of her friends has a parent or sober friend who would be willing to pick them up.  Jessica can pick up the car from school in the morning.  If one of her friends lives nearby, everyone might be able to stay there for the night.  Or, Jessica and her friends can share a cab – 1-888-TAXIGUY is a toll-free number which is available in 250 towns and cities across Ontario.  It connects callers directly to a partner taxicab in their city.  All of these are good options for Jessica and her friends.

JFCY has posted about drinking and driving in the past - check out these past posts for more information: July 2012 ; September 2011

The scenario for this post was written by Deqa Abdi, a volunteer member of the JFCY PLE Team. The legal info was written by JFCY volunteer Leora Jackson, a UofT law student.  Reviewed by JFCY. 

Thursday, January 19, 2012

New Video: Age of Consent


Check out JFCY’s new video on age of consent.  For those of you who want the details in brief, there's a quick summary of the law below:


Consent to sex is always your decision – The Canadian law requires that all people participating in sexual activity must give their own consent: you decide whether you want to be involved in any kind of sexual activity, from kissing and touching to intercourse.  


However, the law sets some limits on that, so that it is illegal if you are below a certain age to be sexually involved with certain other people. This means that if you are too young to consent to sex with a particular person, that older person could be charged with a criminal offence. 

When are you old enough to legally consent to sexual activity?
If you are…

  • 12 or 13, you can consent to sex, but only with someone less than two years older than you.
  • 14 or 15, you can consent to sex, but only with someone who is less than 5 years older than you. But, you CAN'T consent to sex with someone who is more than two years younger than you (or you could be charged).
  • 16 and older, you can consent to sex with anyone older than you. 
  • In all of these cases, however, if you are under 18, you cannot legally consent to sex with someone who is in a position of trust or authority over you (like your teacher, swim coach, Pastor). That person could be charged with a criminal offence.

Read the law: Criminal Code of Canada, s.150.1-153.


Thanks to PLE Team Volunteers Terence Chen (actor and video-editor), Lucas Treleaven (actor and script-writer), Arif Hussain (director), Tracy Chen (filming), Cydney  Kim (brainstorming),  Christine Doucette (law student advisor) and Andrea (script, JFCY lawyer supervisor) for their work on this video!

Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Behind the Scenes with the PLE Team







On December 20 some members of the YouTube Subcommittee of the PLE Team shot a public legal education video. The topic: Age of Consent for Sexual Activity, an area of law that is commonly misunderstood. The volunteers worked with Andrea to come up with a script and plan. Stay tuned for the release of this short video in January 2012. Thanks to everyone who helped: Tracy, Terence, Lucas, Christine, Arif and Andrea


To see more photos, check out our Facebook album FACEBOOK ALBUM

Friday, November 18, 2011

Leaving Home (legal info for youth in Ontario)

Scenario by PLE Team Member Inez Leutenegger, legal info by JFCY
 
To her peers, Lukie has appears to have had a typically ‘normal’ teenage life. Just having turned sixteen two months ago, she has recently received her driver’s permit. She is in grade 11 and enjoys being a part of the school’s cross country and soccer teams. Her friends are a tight knit group who enjoy spending time together. Lukie has always been laid back and easy going, the life of the party who, at the same time, is able to maintain solid grades in her classes at school. 

Image from: http://www.sxc.hu/photo/1170300

Lately, though, Lukie’s friends and teachers have seen a change in her academic, athletic and social life. She has been skipping classes, neglecting her homework and doing bad on tests. As a result, her overall marks are starting to slip, and her teachers are concerned. She seems to be distracted at practices, and her commitment to the sports teams at school seems to be faltering.  She is also becoming increasingly withdrawn and distant from her tight knit group of friends. 

Since her parents’ divorce two years ago, Lukie's home life has been tough. She lives with her mother who  recently lost her job. Money is tight. Her mother’s boyfriend has been living in their home for the past six months, and his violent nature has resulted in the physical abuse of both Lukie and her mother. Lukie has not had contact with her biological father since his parents have separated. 

Lukie is slowly beginning to feel as though her home life is becoming unbearable and does not think she can wait another two years until she has graduated high school to move out. Lukie has been contemplating leaving home and living on her own, but the thought is scary and there are so many questions that run through her head.  She has confided her desire to move away from home to her best friend Brian and his parents, who seem willing to help Lukie in her situation. Lukie must weigh her options before making the big decision to live away from home.


Can Lukie leave home?
Lukie is 16.  According to Ontario law, people who are 16 and older can withdraw from parental control and leave home.  They do not need anyone's permission to do this. However, if youth leave home voluntarily (ie in the absence of abuse, neglect or serious conflict) their parents do not have to support them financially. It can get complicated. Lukie should talk to a family law lawyer about whether her parents owe her a legal obligation to provide her financial support if she leaves home. 

What can Lukie take with her?
Lukie can take all of her personal property with her.  That includes things like clothes or school supplies that only she uses.  It doesn’t matter whether Lukie bought those things or if she received them as a gift.  Lukie should take all of her identification: her health card, birth certificate, and passport, for example. She will need her ID in order to be safe and to access support programs and services.

How can Lukie balance school and work?
Lukie is required to attend school until she is 18 or graduates from high school.  She can get a job – lots of people have jobs in high school – but she cannot work during school hours and the kind of workshe can do might be limited.  For example, she is too young to serve alcohol in a restaurant.  She can also be paid a reduced minimum wage as long as she is in school and working fewer than 28 hours per week.
To learn more about laws relating to youth and work, check out this blog post.


How Else Can Lukie Support Herself?
Lukie may be eligible to receive social assistance through Ontario Works, which is available to 16 and 17 year-olds in special circumstances.  Since Lukie has been a victim of abuse in the home, she should qualify to receive Ontario Works, as long as he is enrolled in full-time school. She may need someone else, such as a Guidance Counselor or social worker, to verify the abuse.

Where can Lukie go to live?
Since Lukie is 16, there are no legal restrictions to her living with Brian’s family. In fact, if Lukie is staying with them long-term then they can ask to have the Child’s Tax Benefit and Ontario Child Benefit paid to them to help support her.  This money is supposed to be paid to the adult who is housing and caring for a minor.  It cannot be paid directly to the minor. Lukie can also rent an apartment to live in by herself.  Because Lukie is sixteen who has withdrawn from parental control, the Ontario Human Rights Code makes it illegal for a landlord to refuse to rent to Lukie just because she is young. 

For more legal information about leaving home, check out this JFCY publication
Leaving home is not easy. There are many social and legal issues that arise for young people. If you are planning to leave home, or you have been forced to leave home, you can call JFCY for legal advice at 416-920-1633.
Leaving Home comic by Adrianna Pahuta, PLE Team Member

Youth Leaving Care Hearings - Nov. 25, 2011



On Fri. Nov.25th, at 10:15 a.m., JFCY lawyers will make submissions at the hearings at the Provincial Legislature, proposing recommendations for child welfare reform. 


JFCY's efforts are led by Staff Lawyer, Niamh Harraher and Street Youth Legal Services Lawyer, Johanna Macdonald.


Niamh and Johanna will be joined by young people who are former Crown Wards and kids who lived in foster care.  


These youth will be sharing their experiences and ideas for how to improve Ontario's Child Welfare system, specifically with respect to the law and issues around youth leaving care as they get older. This is the first time that Canada has had youth-led hearings on these issues.


For more info, check out the official event website, produced by youth organizers from the Office of the Provincial Advocate for Children and Youth. 


Also, check out this article from the Toronto Star, where some of the young people involved share their stories. 

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Late Night Swims in Public Pools: Legal?

Scenario by PLE Team volunteer Stefan Vernier (perhaps dreaming of summer days...)
Photo used with permission from Alyssa Katherine Faoro, akFAORO.com 
On a warm summer night, three friends are hanging out in the parking lot of their local pizza shop. After spending a couple of hours talking to each other, Todd, who is 15, says that he’s getting bored. He suggests that the three of them head down to the park near their community centre, where they can pass around a soccer ball. Kyle and Thomas, who are also 15 years old, agree that they’d have a much better time playing soccer at the park.


When they arrive at the park, they realize that the street lights that illuminate the soccer field have already been turned off. “We’re too late guys,” says Kyle. “The city turns off the lights at 12 a.m.”

Slightly disgruntled, they stare at each other for a few seconds, hoping that the other person would think of something else that they could do to pass the time. Suddenly Todd speaks up. “Hey, you know what would be really fun?” He pauses for a moment, making sure that Kyle and Thomas are listening to what he has to say. “What if we took a swim in the community centre’s outdoor swimming pool, just for a bit?”

Intrigued by the idea, Thomas shouts ecstatically, “Yea, let’s go for it!” 

Kyle, on the other hand, did not share the same excitement. “But they close the pool after 10 p.m. There’s a lock on the front gate for a reason you know,” he says. “I don’t want to get in trouble, guys. The sign on the fence says that we can’t enter when the pool is closed and that we could be fined if we get caught.”

“Okay, suit yourself then,” says Todd, as he and Thomas climb the fence and jump into the pool, which is run by their city’s Parks and Recreation department. The two of them spend another half-hour playing in the pool, while Kyle stands idle outside the fence.

Suddenly, a police car pulls up outside the community centre. An officer walks out and notices the boys swimming.

LEGAL INFO by JFCY

Trespass to Property Act
Ontario has a law that makes trespassing illegal.  A trespasser is someone who is on or is using land that doesn’t belong to them without permission of the person or people who are responsible for and who control that land.  Todd and Thomas are clearly trespassing according to Ontario law, because the locked gate and fence make it clear that the pool shouldn’t be accessed without permission. The signs also make this clear.

Todd and Thomas could be charged with trespassing ("enter premise where entry prohibited").  Since they are breaking provincial law, the section of the Provincial Offences Act that applies to people under age 16 would apply if they were charged.  (This is different from being charged with a criminal offence, where the Youth Criminal Justice Act applies to people under 18.)  There are a number of differences between the treatment of adults who are charged with provincial offences and young people who are charged with the same offences.  One difference is that young peoples' identities are protected from publication.  Another is that there is a limit on penalties for offences:  the maximum a person under age 16 can be fined is $1000, whereas the maximums for adult fines can be much higher. But remember, provincial offences are different than criminal offences (that is a whole other topic!).

Curfew
We’ve covered the curfew issue on the blog before: The Child and Family Services Act says that parents of children under sixteen cannot permit their children to be without an authorized adult in public places between midnight and six am.  Kyle, Todd, and Thomas all fall under this Act, since they are 15.  They shouldn't have been at the swimming pool or even at the park at this time of night. If caught, the police may be take these boys home or even bring them to a children's aid society.

Municipal Bylaws
The sign outside the swimming pool probably refers to the municipal bylaws that regulate public swimming pool access in Todd’s city.  (We explained municipal bylaws previously here!) For example, in Toronto, municipal bylaws say that people must not use public swimming pools outside designated times, and that they must obey the signs posted in or adjacent to the pool.  The police officer can tell Todd and Thomas that they must leave the pool.  The police could also charge these youth with breaching a municipal by-law and the end result could be that they must pay a fine.  As in trespassing, the rules about young people under Provincial Offences Act would apply.

IF YOU ARE A YOUNG PERSON WHO HAS BEEN CHARGED WITH A PROVINCIAL OR MUNICIPAL OFFENCE YOU CAN CALL JFCY FOR LEGAL ADVICE. 416.920.1633



Friday, October 28, 2011

Having Fun on Halloween

- Scenario by Lindsey Erickson and Ouran Li, Legal Information by JFCY


At fifteen years old, Jamie and her friends all agreed they were much too old to be trick-or-treating. This was the first year that they would have a real “grown-up” Halloween: co-ed, costumes, and, of course, alcohol. The group decided that they should definitely throw a party, but since Halloween fell on a weekday, it proved problematic finding a place to throw it. Their entire families would be home and they did not want to risk the consequences of getting caught by their parents, most of whom did not approve of underage drinking.
“We’ll just wing it,” declared Jamie’s best friend Amanda. “My big brother is going to get us a couple of mickies - we’ll find someplace to go.”
Jamie was nervous about the idea, but, not wanting to ruin the fun, she decided she would meet up with her friends on Halloween night.
After putting the finishing touches on her costume, Jamie received a text from Amanda saying that the party was going to be in the park across the school. The group knew that police officers frequented the park, but they were confident the wooded area directly behind would be safe. The signs around the park, however, made it quite clear that it was closed after 11pm. Once again Jamie simply shrugged it off, and headed on over.  It was after midnight by this point.
When Jamie arrived at 12:15am, she saw that the party was less than subtle. Many people were already quite intoxicated. Jamie’s friend Amanda was dancing on the park bench, dangerously close to teetering over.
Jamie had barely a sip of alcohol before she heard sirens. The majority of the party scrambled, rushing off into every direction. The next thing she knew a flashlight was in her face, and a stern voice asking what she was doing. The police had arrived.

What are the potential legal consequences for Jamie?

Underage drinking
Since Jamie and Amanda are both under 19, ss.30(8) of the Liquor Licence Act makes it illegal for them to have or consume alcohol.  While there are certain exceptions to this prohibition, drinking in the park on Halloween isn’t one of them!

Breaking curfew
One problem that Jamie and Amanda face is that they were out in a public place after midnight.  The Child and Family Services Act says that parents of children under sixteen cannot permit their children to be without an authorized adult in public places between midnight and six am.

Municipal bylaws
In addition to breaking Ontario laws, Jamie and Amanda could be breaking municipal bylaws of the town/city where they live.  Bylaws are the laws that are created by a city or a town.  For example, the City of Toronto has a whole chapter in its bylaws about the proper use of public parks.  One of the rules says that consuming, serving, or selling alcohol in a public park is not allowed without a licence from the Liquor Licence Board of Ontario.  Another one says that no one is allowed to gather in a public park after midnight and before 5:30 am without a special permit.  These are rules that apply to everyone, regardless of their age.
Curfew comic by PLE Team member Arif Hussain
Lindsey Erickson is a Paralegal Student at Seneca College, and Ouran Li is studying to be a Law Clerk at Seneca College.  They are volunteer members of the PLE Team at JFCY.

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

The Legal Rules of Youth and Work

Starting your first job?

Did you know there are laws about young people in the workforce? 

Consider these scenarios

Mandeep is 14 years old and just started a summer job working at a construction project lifting supplies.

Jillian, age 15 decides to start a part time job which requires her to work during school hours. She starts the job immediately, without letting anyone know.

Marcel, 17 is super excited to for all the tips he will make by serving at a local bar which is licensed to serve alcohol.

Are they all allowed to be employed at these jobs?

MANDEEP:
According to Construction Projects Regulation under the Occupational Health and Safety Act, John cannot be employed at a construction project or be present in such a workplace while work is being performed. This is because the law says you must be at least 16 years old to work in these types of jobs. 

JILLIAN:
Jillian's employment during school hours violates the Education Act and Supervised Alternative Learning and Other Excusals from Attendance at School Regulation. These laws say that, "A child required to attend school cannot be employed during school hours. After directing an inquiry into the matter, the Provincial School Attendance Counsellor may excuse a child from attendance for various motives, including if he/she has obtained a secondary school graduation diploma or has completed a course of equivalent standing."

Parents and guardians who neglect or refuse to cause a young person to attend school can be charged and made to attend court. This does not apply if the young person is 16 or over and has withdrawn from parental control (ie left home). Thinking of skipping school to work?  You need to know that if you are under age 16 and you skip school regularly YOU can be charged with an offence and brought to court.  And your employer can also be charged if they employ you during work hours when you are under age 16. These laws have actually been changed to make the magic age 18, however, they have not yet been "proclaimed" by the government and thus the old rule of age 16 still stands. 


So, our advice: go to school during the day and work in the evenings and on the weekends!


MARCEL:
Marcel cannot be employed at a bar serving alcohol, as he is under 18. The Liquor Licence Act and Licence to Sell Liquor Regulation states that people under age 18 cannot be employed to sell or serve liquor on licensed premises. Note, however, that with few exceptions young people are not legally allowed to consume alcohol until they are age 19. So they can serve it when they are 18 but not drink it. Weird?

For the keeners who want to read more,
Ontario Ministry of Labour website:

Feeling even more keen, check out the Education Act:  http://www.e-laws.gov.on.ca/html/statutes/english/elaws_statutes_90e02_e.htm#BK27 (especially sections 21(1), (2), 24, 30(3)

Blog post written by volunteer PLE Team Member Julia Dmitrieva and JFCY staff lawyer, with help from JFCY law student Jesse Gutman. 
Julia and fellow PLE Team Member at the JFCY office...not during school hours!

Friday, September 9, 2011

Drunk Driving

Scenario (by Cydney Kim)

Michael and Fred are 16 year old friends who love parties. One night, they decide to attend a party at the other end of town. Michael arranges to be picked up by his parents late at night. When Fred’s 20 year old brother drops the two friends off at the party, he leaves his car there for Fred to use.

The party is far from over when Michael suddenly gets a headache and decides to go home. Although Fred offers to drive him home in his brother’s car, Michael is unsure whether Fred can actually drive. Fred assures him that he has just received his ‘G1’ and has been taking driving lessons. However, Michael refuses and Fred drives off alone in anger.

Meanwhile, Michael’s parents are at home enjoying a bit of whiskey. When they receive Michael’s call, they don’t feel drunk at all and head towards the party, with Michael’s mom driving. As soon as Michael steps into the car, he senses that his parents seem a bit weird but he doesn’t say anything and they head home. 

Both Fred and Michael’s mom get stopped by the cops that night.

What are Fred’s legal issues?  What are Michael’s mom’s legal issues? 

Both Fred and Michael’s mom could be charged with criminal offences as a result of their actions.

Adult charges

If Michael’s mom had enough alcohol, she could be charged with impaired driving. Impaired driving, which means driving while your ability is affected by alcohol or drugs, is a crime under the Criminal Code of Canada under Section 253(1)(a). Across Canada, it is a criminal offence to operate a vehicle while impaired and/or while having a blood alcohol content  of 80 milligrams of alcohol in 100 millilitres of blood or more. If someone is convicted, they can lose their license, be fined, or spend time in jail. The vehicle does not even have to be moving; you can be charged if you are impaired behind the wheel, even if you have not started to drive.

Youth Charges

Fred’s legal issues are different since he is 16 years old and does not have a licence. He could still be found guilty of the same criminal offences as Michael’s mom.  However, different procedures apply to Fred since he is under age 18. The Youth Criminal Justice Act applies to his situation, and this changes the way the police officer must interact with Fred. For example, s. 146 of the Act imposes a different way to obtain evidence, not binding youth to certain written and/or oral statements. He has the right to have a parent present when he is being questioned by the police.  The Act also leaves open a larger and more varied sentencing options and ways of resolving cases.  If Fred decides to plead guilty, or loses a trial, he would not be “convicted” of the offences.  Unlike adults, youth are “found guilty”.  (The records system for youth is also very different than for adults, but that is a story for another day…)

Graduated Licensing

In Ontario, as of August 1, 2010 fully licensed drivers who are 21 and under or a novice driver in the Graduate Licensing System (GLS), caught with any alcohol in their blood, will receive an immediate 24-hour roadside driver license suspension and, if convicted, face a fine of $60-$500 and a 30-day license suspension.

Driving with a G1 without a fully licensed supervisor is a separate offence which would result in the temporary suspension of Fred’s licence. 


If you are a youth charged with an offence, check this info pamphlet for more info.

Cydney Kim is a grade 11 student at University of Toronto Schools. She wrote the fact scenario.  The legal information was written by McGill law student Jesse Gutman and JFCY lawyers.

Monday, June 27, 2011

Your Age and the Law

Have you ever wanted to know how old you have to be in order to legally do something?

Like stay out late, leave school, or get married?

Check out this JFCY pamphlet for a whole bunch of different legal facts on Your Age and the Law! http://www.jfcy.org/PDFs/Age_Based_Laws_May_2008.pdf