Tuesday, October 28, 2014
Join us for our AGM & Fundraiser on International Child Day - November 20, 2014
It is that time of year when we reach out - to
invite you to celebrate, and ask for your support in meeting the needs of our
vulnerable clients.
Friday, October 3, 2014
PRESS RELEASE: Conservative Government’s last minute appeal of Federal Court ruling on refugee health cuts prolongs unnecessary suffering
TORONTO, ON – October 1, 2014 – At the very last legal minute, the Conservative Government has appealed the Federal Court decision on refugee health care to the Federal Court of Appeal. Canadian Doctors for Refugee Care (CDRC), the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers (CARL), and Justice for Children and Youth (JFCY), all parties to the original court action, denounced the government’s decision today as cynical and irresponsible.
"It's another sad day for refugees”, said Dr. Philip Berger, founding member of Canadian Doctors for Refugee Care and Medical Director, Inner City Health Program at St. Michael’s Hospital. “The Conservative Government is recklessly choosing to let vulnerable people, including pregnant women and ill children, suffer rather than accept the very clear and comprehensive decision of the court".
On July 4, Justice Mactavish of the Federal Court ruled that the federal cabinet’s cuts to refugee health care were “cruel and unusual treatment” and thus a violation of s. 12 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The court also ruled that the health cuts were inequitable and discriminatory, and therefore breached the Charter’s s.15 equality guarantee.
“The government is in denial”, added Lorne Waldman, President of CARL and lead counsel on the case. “The factual conclusions of the court were clear: before the cuts, refugees received no more than basic health care; secondly, the cuts applied to all refugees save Government Assisted Refugees, not only fraudulent claims, as the government alleged; finally, the cuts put lives at risk. The government’s bafflegab about cutting health care to keep fraudulent refugees out of Canada, was exactly that – bafflegab. It was a smokescreen for a wrong-headed policy and the Federal Court shot it down.”
This latest government action is particularly curious given a recent Forum opinion poll revealed Canadians are not in favour of providing refugees with less access to health care.
Mitchell Goldberg, Vice-president of CARL called the government’s decision to appeal shockingly cynical. “They know the health cuts put lives at risk. Rather than reinstating the refugee health program, they delayed their appeal to the last minute. What part of ‘lives at risk’ do they not understand?”
The government has also asked the Court of Appeal to stay the court order until the appeal is decided which means many more months where refugees continue to be denied health care. The group plans to vigorously oppose the government’s stay motion, as well as its appeal.
“The government knows it is wrong on this issue” said Dr. Meb Rashid, founding member of Canadian Doctors for Refugee Care and medical director of the Crossroads Clinic at Women's College Hospital. “More than 20 national health organizations and every provincial health minister representing various political parties have called on the government to reverse their dangerous cuts. What will it take for the Conservative Government to listen?”
-30-
For further information contact: Lorne Waldman (CARL): 416.254.4590 | lorne@lornewaldman.ca
Mitchell Goldberg (CARL en français): 514.844.7528 | mitchell.goldberg@gmail.com
Christopher Holcroft (CDRC): 416.996.0767 | Chris_Holcroft@yahoo.com
Emily Chan (JFCY): 416-920-1633 | chane@lao.on.ca
Tuesday, September 9, 2014
"Especially and Particularly": How The Charter Rights of Children Are Finally Being Granted Unique Consideration By The Courts
Written by JFCY guest blogger: Brock
Jones, Crown Counsel, Crown Law Criminal; Adjunct Professor, Faculty of Law,
University of Toronto. This is written in a personal capacity and does not reflect the views of the Attorney General of Ontario nor the Office of the Crown Law Criminal.
Should children be entitled to different constitutional protections from the courts than similarly situated adults?
Should children be entitled to different constitutional protections from the courts than similarly situated adults?
Canadian law has long recognized the
inherent vulnerability of children and the need to provide them with particular
protections in a variety of contexts. Yet, surprisingly, the courts have been
reluctant to explicitly hold that the Charter
of Rights and Freedoms bestows upon children any enhanced constitutional protections. For example, over 20 years ago, in R v M. (G.C.), the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that young persons are not to
be granted a “special constitutional guarantee” which would differ in substance
to that available to adults.
Yet two recent judgments – decided in
very different contexts – may signal a tipping point has been reached where
courts are finally willing to recognize that violations of children’s
constitutional rights should be viewed differently – and inevitably more
significantly – than those of adults. This blog post will address the Ontario
Court of Appeal’s decision in R. v S.B. 2014
ONCA 576 (decided under s. 11(e) of the Charter) and the Federal Court’s
decision in Canadian Doctors for Refugee Care v
Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration)
2014 FC 651 (decided in part under s. 12 of the Charter) and their potential
implications.
On April 3, 2011 a search warrant was executed on
S.B.’s residence. Two loaded guns were found in his closet. He was arrested and
held for a bail hearing. The case was adjourned, first on consent, to April 6,
and then over the objections of S.B.’s counsel to April 14. The Crown sought
his detention, but he was released by the youth justice court. He was 17, and
had no prior record.
At trial, S.B. claimed that his rights under section 11(e) of the Charter were violated. Section 11(e) provides that any person charged with an offence is “not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause.” The delay of 12 days before S.B. could have his bail hearing was found to violate this provision by the trial judge and this decision was upheld on appeal.
S.B. sought a stay of proceedings of the charges he faced as a remedy under section 24(1) of the Charter. While the Court of Appeal ultimately upheld the trial judge’s decision to decline such a remedy, the Court did make several findings worthy of note.
First, it held that the delay in obtaining a bail hearing for 12 days for S.B. undermined the integrity of the justice system. S.B.’s status as a young person, that he had no record, and that he “probably” would have been released in any event were noted as significant factors to weigh.[1]
At trial, S.B. claimed that his rights under section 11(e) of the Charter were violated. Section 11(e) provides that any person charged with an offence is “not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause.” The delay of 12 days before S.B. could have his bail hearing was found to violate this provision by the trial judge and this decision was upheld on appeal.
S.B. sought a stay of proceedings of the charges he faced as a remedy under section 24(1) of the Charter. While the Court of Appeal ultimately upheld the trial judge’s decision to decline such a remedy, the Court did make several findings worthy of note.
First, it held that the delay in obtaining a bail hearing for 12 days for S.B. undermined the integrity of the justice system. S.B.’s status as a young person, that he had no record, and that he “probably” would have been released in any event were noted as significant factors to weigh.[1]
The
Court had particularly strong language for the conduct of the Crown, which had
been responsible for much of the delay:
The Crown’s conduct failed to take into
consideration the need, especially
for young persons, for an early bail hearing. As the trial judge said: “The
fact that the declaration of principle in the Y.C.J.A. refers
to special considerations which apply in respect to proceedings against young
persons should compel all persons participating in the proceedings to guard
against infringements.[2]
The emphasis is my own, but the point is clear: the
infringement of S.B.’s constitutional right was “especially” significant due to
his status as a young person.
In Canadian
Doctors the applicants challenged the constitutionality of the Federal
government’s 2012 cuts to health insurance coverage for refugee claimants. The
result of the cuts was to significantly reduce the level of health care
available to these individuals, and all but eliminate it for some pursuing
risk-based claims.
Some 21 national medical organizations offered statements expressing concerns with respect to the cuts. Expert evidence filed in the application noted that the lack of health insurance would have a “detrimental impact on the health of children.” The President of the Paediatric Chairs of Canada criticized the cuts as well and warned against the negative impact they would have on children’s health outcomes.
The applicants (including JFCY) alleged these cuts violated sections 7, 12 and 15 of the Charter. It is under the Court’s section 12 analysis that the most powerful findings with respect to the rights of children may be found.
Section 12 of the Charter prohibits “cruel and unusual treatment or punishment.” As held by the Supreme Court of Canada in penal cases, only treatment or punishment that “shocks the conscience” of the community and “outrages our standards of decency” will rise to the level of a breach of this section.
In paragraph 11 of the judgment the Federal Court found that the health care cuts in question met this very high standard. The cuts constituted cruel and unusual treatment “particularly, but not exclusively”, as they affected children who had been brought to Canada by their parents.
The Court further held that the modifications to the health care program in fact
Some 21 national medical organizations offered statements expressing concerns with respect to the cuts. Expert evidence filed in the application noted that the lack of health insurance would have a “detrimental impact on the health of children.” The President of the Paediatric Chairs of Canada criticized the cuts as well and warned against the negative impact they would have on children’s health outcomes.
The applicants (including JFCY) alleged these cuts violated sections 7, 12 and 15 of the Charter. It is under the Court’s section 12 analysis that the most powerful findings with respect to the rights of children may be found.
Section 12 of the Charter prohibits “cruel and unusual treatment or punishment.” As held by the Supreme Court of Canada in penal cases, only treatment or punishment that “shocks the conscience” of the community and “outrages our standards of decency” will rise to the level of a breach of this section.
In paragraph 11 of the judgment the Federal Court found that the health care cuts in question met this very high standard. The cuts constituted cruel and unusual treatment “particularly, but not exclusively”, as they affected children who had been brought to Canada by their parents.
The Court further held that the modifications to the health care program in fact
…potentially jeopardize the health, the safety and indeed the very
lives, of these innocent and vulnerable children in a manner that shocks the
conscience and outrages our standards of decency.[3]
The “cruelty” of the cuts, which could lead to “unnecessary pain and suffering”, was “especially evident insofar as they affected children.”[4] Children, the Court emphasized, who were entirely innocent and subject to the whims of their parents’ decisions.[5]
Potential For A New Paradigm?
Thus, “especially” and “particularly”, the Charter rights of these children were found to have been breached. It should be noted that in neither case did the Court find that a similarly situated adult would not have had his or her Charter rights violated as well. (Indeed, in Canadian Doctors the court expressly found both adults and children had their Charter rights violated.)
But by noting that the violations in question took on an enhanced or unique status given that the applicants were children, the Courts may be slowly opening the door to a formal recognition that state conduct must, in certain circumstances, be held to a higher standard of scrutiny and care when the constitutional rights of children are at stake.
Wednesday, May 14, 2014
JFCY supports Children and Youth in Care Day
STATEMENT
Toronto, Ontario, 14 May 2014 – Justice for Children and Youth
(JFCY) is pleased to recognize Ontario’s first annual Children and Youth in
Care Day, and affirm our dedication to assisting youth in and leaving
care. Our clinic regularly helps young
people navigate the often complex web of legal and non-legal issues that come
with being in care or leaving care.
Children and youth in and leaving
care face a number of challenges in education, social life, and housing
arrangements. It is our collective
responsibility to provide excellent care and seamless transition plans for
youth in and leaving care. The Youth
Leaving Care Hearings held at Queen’s Park in 2011 highlighted the need for
change. Positive changes undertaken by
the Ontario government since that time include:
- Better accessibility to services if a young person leaves care and would like to re-enter;
- Extended services to youth transitioning out of care who are still in school; and
- Further supports to youth transitioning out of care through the Youth-In-Transition worker positions created by the Ministry of Children and Youth Services.
More change is needed. JFCY continues to advocate for equality to
all youth in our care system which stands in the position of the young person’s
legal guardian. A gap in service still
exists for 16 and 17 year olds accessing care for the first time. Youth needing care after they turn 16 are
left with few choices to sustain their safety and security, often leaving them
with no option but the shelter system or the streets.
This first annual Child and Youth
in Care Day, let us all recognize the bravery and resilience of children and
youth in care, and affirm our support to them. We look forward to working with young persons, community members, and
the government to continue to strive to meet the needs of young people in
Ontario.
Tuesday, April 29, 2014
R v Manitowabi: The Significance - and Limits - of a Diagnosis of FASD for Young Persons Involved in the Criminal Justice System
The Ontario Court of Appeal released a ground-breaking
decision today on the significance of a diagnosis of fetal alcohol spectrum
disorders (“FASD”) for young persons in criminal. While the Court clearly
acknowledged the nature of FASD and its implications for criminal culpability,
it also put significant limits on the use of such a diagnosis unless
specifically applied to the facts of a particular case.
The
Facts of R v
Manitowabi 2014
ONCA 301
Dakota Manitowabi was 16 years of age at the time of his
offence. He attended a party where he was not invited and was asked to leave by
the homeowner. He did leave, but returned with a large knife. When confronted
about his presence again, he stabbed the homeowner once in his torso. The
victim died approximately 15 minutes later.
At trial, Manitowabi did not dispute he committed the
stabbing but argued he lacked the intent to kill and should not be found guilty
of murder. The defence failed and he was found guilty of second degree murder.
The judge imposed an adult sentence of life without parole for seven years (the
maximum sentence possible) and also lifted the ban on the publication of his
identity.[2]
What is
FASD?
FASD refers to a
wide array of behavioural and intellectual difficulties associated with damage
to the human brain caused by exposure to alcohol during pregnancy. Current
research suggests the prevalence of FASD in the general population of between
2-5%[3],
and the rate in prisons (both juvenile and adult) could be at least 10 -15
times that number.[4]
In Manitowabi, the
Court of Appeal noted the following about FASD at paragraph 40:
FASD is a permanent
neurodevelopmental disorder. It is an umbrella term describing a range of
effects that can occur in an individual whose mother drank alcohol during
pregnancy. Those effects can include physical, mental, behavioural and learning
disability. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome (“FAS”) describes the most severe
manifestation of the disorder…[5]
The Court continued to note that FASD “impacts on executive
functioning”, which in turn refers to “specific cognitive skills”, including
the ability to grasp “cause and effect.”[6]
However, it cautioned that the expert testimony in the case before it warned
that executive functioning is an “ambiguous” term referable to a “wide variety
of cognitive abilities”, whose deficits are “inherently difficult to measure.”[7]
Does a
Diagnosis of FASD matter?
At trial, it was unclear if Manitowabi suffered from FASD
and thus defence counsel did not vigorously pursue its significance. By the
time of the appeal, several years later, the Court of Appeal had expert
evidence before it which established as a probability the appellant suffered
from some form of FASD.
The Court accepted that FASD and its effect on executive
functioning could be relevant to both a young person’s guilt at trial and his
or her moral culpability for the purposes of sentencing. However, it also noted
that the “impact of FASD on executive functioning will vary from individual to
individual and will vary for the same person from situation to situation.”[8] A
blanket, abstract diagnosis of FASD will thus be of limited value.
Rather, clinical tests conducted by an expert witness that
will assist with understanding the particular impact of FASD on the young
person before the court were recommended. Additionally, the Court of Appeal
emphasized that the significance of an FASD diagnosis must be tailored to the
specific crime before the youth justice court.
Thus, in Manitowabi’s appeal, the expert evidence presented
did not assist with the specific circumstances of the case – that is, whether
or not his probable affliction of FASD impacted on his ability to foresee the
consequences of stabbing the victim.[9]
And while such a diagnosis could “attenuate
the moral blameworthiness” of a young offender, since it was not established
FASD was relevant to the specific crime in question (i.e. murder), it “could
not shed any new light on the appellant’s moral blameworthiness.”[10] As
a result, both the conviction and adult sentence were upheld.
Implications
for Future Cases
Following Manitowabi, there
can be no doubt a diagnosis of FASD for a young person is highly relevant in
youth criminal proceedings. But counsel must be cautioned against relying on a
mere abstract diagnosis and arguing their client is therefore entitled to an
acquittal at trial or mitigation at sentencing. Rather, an expert opinion,
specifically tailored to the exact criminal acts in question, must be
proffered.
Obtaining an expert opinion that a young person suffers from
FASD is already a challenging hurdle for the defence to overcome, as it
typically requires the young person’s mother to admit to drinking during
pregnancy. Once obtained, its value to the defence is often simply presumed as
it establishes a highly mitigating factor. Following Manitowabi, that would be a serious mistake.
While it is incumbent upon all participants in the youth
criminal justice system to acknowledge the prevalence of mental health concerns
among young persons appearing in the criminal courts, the highly individualized
nature of each particular case must always be appreciated.
Resources
Available Online
Thankfully, a wide variety of resources exist online to help
interested parties learn more about FASD.
FASD
Ontario Network of Expertise (FASD ONE) is a group that works together
to address issues related to Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) in the
province of Ontario. Membership includes experts and specialists in research,
health promotion, diagnosis, justice services, community and policy
development, and service delivery as well as family members who have intimate
knowledge of the practical needs of individuals with this disability. Their
website has more information including contact numbers for local diagnostic
clinics: http://www.fasdontario.ca/cms/resources/diagnostic-clinics
An excellent guidebook for
educational practitioners can be ordered online from http://www.motherisk.org for a small
fee: http://www.motherisk.org/documents/understandingFASD_OrderForm.pdf
[1] Brock Jones, Crown Counsel, Crown Law
Criminal; Adjunct Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Toronto. Any views
expressed herein are mine alone and do not represent those of the Crown Law
Office nor the Ministry of the Attorney General.
[2]
The Youth Criminal Justice Act prohibits the publication of information
that would identify a young people as having been dealt with under the Act
(s.110 and related sections).
[3] May, P.A., Gossage, J.P., Kalberg, W.O., Robinson, L.K., Bucley, D.,
Manning, M. 2009. FASD from various research methods with an emphasis on recent
in-school studies. Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews 15: 176-192.
[4] http://www.johnhowardbc.ca/images/jhsbc-factsheet-fasd.pdf
[5] R
v Manitowabi 2014 ONCA 301 at para 40
[6] Ibid.
at para 41
[7] Ibid.
at para 42
[8] Ibid.
at para 43
[9] Ibid.
at para 58.
[10] Ibid.
at paras. 64-65
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
Have You Been Carded?
You’re
walking home after school and from the corner of your eye you
notice a police cruiser approaching you. You think nothing of it, as you
haven’t committed a crime.
Not too long after, you hear a “hey you” from the direction of the cruiser, and find the officer inside motioning at you to come over. You approach and the officer asks you, “where were you going?” and “do you have anything illegal on you.” and then continues with, “you matched the description of a suspect in nearby house break-ins” or “we’re looking for someonen who matches your description.” Finally, they end by asking for you for identification or to give them personal information such as your name, age and address.
The collection of this information being collected on a Toronto Police form and entered into a database is often referred to as “carding”. Carding is an unfortunate reality for many youths, and disproportionately so, for young males who are ethnic minorities. In law, when an individual is approached by an officer and asked for personal information, the person can decline to answer as his or her right to remain silent are protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. However, failing to answer or not cooperating can lead to greater problems. Each person must decide what to do in this situation.
Not too long after, you hear a “hey you” from the direction of the cruiser, and find the officer inside motioning at you to come over. You approach and the officer asks you, “where were you going?” and “do you have anything illegal on you.” and then continues with, “you matched the description of a suspect in nearby house break-ins” or “we’re looking for someonen who matches your description.” Finally, they end by asking for you for identification or to give them personal information such as your name, age and address.
The collection of this information being collected on a Toronto Police form and entered into a database is often referred to as “carding”. Carding is an unfortunate reality for many youths, and disproportionately so, for young males who are ethnic minorities. In law, when an individual is approached by an officer and asked for personal information, the person can decline to answer as his or her right to remain silent are protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. However, failing to answer or not cooperating can lead to greater problems. Each person must decide what to do in this situation.
![]() |
| http://csg.lao.on.ca/ |
Why do officers randomly collect personal information from the public?
The police justify carding as a method to reduce crime in high-risk communities. Police officers are asked to document their daily practice and to be as detailed as possible, this includes taking notes of incidents as they happen and documenting their interactions with the members of the public. Large quantifies of carding forms are completed by the police in the identified communities. Additionally, filling out these carding forms is regarded by the police as good police work because the information collected is entered into large databases that the police use to search for connections, persons of interest, and bystanders of previous crimes.
Problems with "carding"
The police have been under
heavy scrutiny in Toronto (as well as in other
large cities such as New York USA and London UK) because research shows that the police stop racial minorities more frequently. A Toronto Star article reported that the number of black youths carded in Toronto over the last five years is equivalent to the number of black youths in the city itself.
The finding that minorities, such as African-Canadians, are stopped for carding at a higher rate than other groups is problematic. The Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Ontario Human Rights Code both protect individuals against discriminatory treatment. As representatives of the state, police officers should be held to an especially high standard. In targeting ethnic and racial minorities over other groups, the Toronto police has potentially violated the fundamental rights of many innocent citizens and there is a Stop Police Carding Campaign: http://stoppolicecarding.com/
Recommendations for improvement
In response to the over-use of carding by the Toronto police, the the Toronto Chief of Police Bill Blair is required to release statistics of individuals being carded every three months, and to directly address discriminatory practices by law enforcement authorities. The police may soon be required to give out "receipts" or copies of the completed information form that also states the purpose each stop. Other suggestions that have been made to improve police practices includes the development of stricter criteria for carding, strengthening diversity training for law enforcement teams, and limiting the amount of time for retaining personal information.
Reference: http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/2013/11/18/toronto_police_urged_to_stop_carding.html
The finding that minorities, such as African-Canadians, are stopped for carding at a higher rate than other groups is problematic. The Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Ontario Human Rights Code both protect individuals against discriminatory treatment. As representatives of the state, police officers should be held to an especially high standard. In targeting ethnic and racial minorities over other groups, the Toronto police has potentially violated the fundamental rights of many innocent citizens and there is a Stop Police Carding Campaign: http://stoppolicecarding.com/
Recommendations for improvement
In response to the over-use of carding by the Toronto police, the the Toronto Chief of Police Bill Blair is required to release statistics of individuals being carded every three months, and to directly address discriminatory practices by law enforcement authorities. The police may soon be required to give out "receipts" or copies of the completed information form that also states the purpose each stop. Other suggestions that have been made to improve police practices includes the development of stricter criteria for carding, strengthening diversity training for law enforcement teams, and limiting the amount of time for retaining personal information.
Reference: http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/2013/11/18/toronto_police_urged_to_stop_carding.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

